Category Archives: TVC

This is how we waste marketing money. Marketing lessons case study. 

Marketing - Branding Case StudyMarketing communication is one activity where a lot of wastage of marketing money is possible if not done strategically.
In their over enthusiasm to be visible any how, companies end up making a lot of ineffective marketing noise, burning a lot of money.

Here is a recent example I saw.

The brand is Cello Butterflow pens. (Here is the ad.)

The target customer shown in the TVC is a young, impressionable girl.

The advertisement features Pankaj Udhas, the famous ghazal singer.

The ad looks quite decent from creative and execution standpoints.

But marketing effectiveness?

In my opinion, very low.

Why?

Because of the lack,of effective marketing strategy.

  • Look at these questions and it will be clear:
How many young girls of today WRITE love letters?
  • 
How many WRITE anything other than exam papers?
  • Who sends letters by post?
  • By the way, how many girls of today know who is Pankaj Udhas ?
  • How many appreciate Ghazals?

(I respect Pankaj Udhas as a popular ghazal singer of my generation. But I don’t see any relevance today using him to sell pens to the younger generation who don’t even know who he is.)

Overall, the communication, even though interesting, is irrelevant for the brand building purpose. The target customer should have been kept in mind before designing the communication. Using whatever is available cheaply in marketing is a bad tactic. That signifies absence of a thoughtful marketing communication strategy.

A father does not decide to marry off his young daughter to a 55 year old famous man because he is available today. Does he?

Then why should we select a brand ambassador who has no relevance to the target customer today?

We should not spend marketing money just to make some noise.

Noise is easy.

Voice needs a strategy.

So does effective marketing.

Why products fail?

It is not rocket science to understand why products fail. Good or bad products can be identified by the quality of their advertisement campaigns. These days, an advertisement of a chewing gum is appearing on TV. It promotes the chewing gum that can help you take fast decisions and make smart choices. This is a perfect example of a mediocre advertisement. There is nothing good about the TVC. The theme is outright downmarket and dirty. The cast is of that calibre only. The storyline is also very very distasteful. It cannot be worse. The advertisement is showing three teenager boys ogling at titillating film posters or some real girls partying or taking a swim in a pond. The whole idea is horrible distasteful. First of all, the boys are shown of very tender age. No parent would like to see the advertisements like this along with their teenagers.It is utterly disgusting, to say the least.

The production quality of the advertisement is also very poor. The voice over is so unclear that the name of the product cannot be heard. Same is with the visual of product logo. Even after seeing the advertisement for 10-15 times, you may not understand what is the NAME of the product….!

Looking at the advertisement, you may feel that mediocrity works in groups. The product, the marketing and the advertising team all have proved that mediocre people find each other and produce mediocrity with zeal.

And to top that, one music channel had that product as sponsor of today’s Valentine’s Day… One more mediocre adding itself to the gang….!

No wonder, mediocre products fail. And I must say, they must. Miserably…Even if they are made by great companies. Finally, great companies also have mediocre people occupying privileged positions on its desks. I wish the good sense prevails in the company.